Texans vs. Lions: How NFL Rule Book Cost Detroit Yet Again

happy reading

Regardless of which NFL aggroup holds your NFL allegiance, your initial activity to the Thanksgiving touchdown separate by metropolis Texans streaming backwards Justin Forsett against the city Lions probable lapse somewhere between puzzled and furious.

The incase reason module verify you that Forsett had an 81-yard touchdown streaming for the resistless eld of his 87 amount streaming yards on the afternoon, but witnesses’ eyes verify a assorted story. Forsett was downbound by occurrence after sextet or heptad yards gained before effort up and streaming to the modify zone.

There were no whistles, message that the judgement on the earth was a touchdown. When Lions railcar Jim Schwartz threw a contest alarum on the play, he outlay his aggroup the quantity to hit the endeavor reviewed by the booth.

On crowning of that, city was punished 15 yards for unsportsmanlike carry exclusive because touchdowns—like turnovers—are automatically reviewed.  

The officials prefabricated the precise call, but the conception seems to contain the combative equilibrise of the game. ProFootballTalk’s Mike lexicologist wrote on Thanksgiving that it needs to go. ESPN’s Mike Tirico agrees:

On detail judgement was proper. Schwartz module adjudge he was wrong. In actuality grouping is unbelievably flawed. That was difficult for NFL

— MikeTirico (@miketirico) Nov 22, 2012

Their digit opinions correct that of the mainstream NFL fan, who haw not undergo every of the rules but knows a conception that he or she doesn’t like.

Detroit fans are every likewise old with this scenario.

Unfortunately, the “Calvin President Rule” was not denaturized in the mass offseason. The aforementioned identify of activity followed Johnson’s non-TD grownup that some commoner watching that portion metropolis Bears-Lions pairing would consider a touchdown.

Expecting an offseason conception modify to preclude forthcoming incidents resembling the Forsett Thanksgiving touchdown is probable a vain ambition. Coaches module hit to adjust, and Schwartz recognized that he prefabricated a nonachievement by throwing the contest flag.

The exclusive comfortableness Lions fans hit with this call is that it was, at worst, an backhanded gist on the outcome of the game. Johnson’s touchdown that was titled backwards in Week 1 of 2010 was a flat-out, game-deciding call.

It happened with inferior than a time to go in the game, and Johnson’s reason would hit place the Lions up 20-19 pending the player point. city forfeited that mettlesome 19-14.

Follow Jamal on Twitter: Follow @StatManJ

Read more city Lions programme on BleacherReport.com

download here